CertNova
Free Rejected CBA Sample · Assessor Comments

See exactly why a P.Eng CBA was returned with comments.

A real, anonymised rejected Competency-Based Assessment, competency by competency. Read the actual assessor's comment, then open CertNova's review notes and the suggested rewrite that answers it. The first competency is open below; a short form unlocks the rest.

Got comments on your own CBA? See what a returned CBA means at your association, and send your comments for a free 15-minute review.

  • Real assessor comments, anonymised
  • Built by Canadian P.Eng professionals
  • Maps each comment to a fix
  • Educational use · No approval guaranteed

Assessor's comment: why 1.1 was returned

Assessor 1: Unclear what was the role of the XYZ in the project. It appears the XYZ only witnessed the Shaftline correction process and verified the resultant values. XYZ needs to explain how they applied engineering principles and skills to meet the specific code requirements referenced. Be specific and detailed about the code requirements and the engineering actions they personally took to comply with them. CEATI looks to be an industry network that publishes some guidelines but wouldn't necessarily fit the "regulations, codes and standards" such as API, ASME, CSA, etc. Further detail to specific clauses and to what work the XYZ did is required to meet the competency requirements.

Tap a numbered marker to read the reviewer's note.

Rejected CBAMechanical / Power

Regulations, Codes & Standards: This competency is intended to demonstrate your knowledge and awareness of Canadian regulations, codes and standards. This includes local engineering procedures and practices as applicable.

Situation

XYZ was mandated to perform a mechanical maintenance of units G4, G5 and G9 at XYZ, run by XYZ. My task was to visit the site & support site managers and crew for shaftline assessment and at site issue resolution.

Action

I visited the XYZ site in XYZ during the maintenance and took following actions Before visiting made sure I will be able toperform shaftline analysis at site as time is of importance. I winesssed the Shaftline corrections were conducted for Units 4, 5, and 9 done by the crew. The focus was on aligning the units according to CEATI standards, specifically addressing axis verticality, guide bearing straightness, and runout at critical points such as the turbine bearing and shaft seal. Measurements from dial indicators at 3 different locations were provided to me I calculated the resultant values for various outcomes like concentricity of runner with discharge ring., straightness at lower guide bearing, verticality of rotating axis, runout at lower guide bearing , run-out at turbine guide bearing and to make sure all the values were under the tolerance limits as per CEATI standard Part V.

Outcome

Recommndation for all units were provided for adjustments. Following adjustments, corrections were performed and unit was within tolerance as per CEATI standard. Resultant Verticality: CEATI tolerance of 0.00072 in/ft. Concentricity of Runner: The tolerance limit of 0.019 inches. Runout at Turbine Bearing: Within the 0.034 inches tolerance.

Six more rejected competencies are waiting

Tell us where you are in your CBA journey, and all seven competencies, with their assessor comments and fixes, unlock straight away.

What the assessor comments reveal

Three reasons assessors return a CBA, from the comments above

Wrong example for the competency

A contractual obligation used for the Code of Ethics, or a product standard used for the Role of Regulatory Bodies. The example must match what the competency asks.

Missing the specific clause

Naming a guideline instead of a recognised standard, with no section or clause, no statement of what it required, and nothing on what you personally did about it.

No personal contribution

Writing that you witnessed or supported the work instead of the engineering decisions, calculations, and judgment that were yours.

Rejected CBA & Assessor Comments FAQ

It is a real, anonymised P.Eng Competency-Based Assessment (CBA) that was returned with assessor comments. For each competency you can read the actual assessor's comment, then open CertNova's review notes and the suggested rewrite that addresses it, the same way CertNova reviews a CBA before resubmission.

The seven assessor comments in this sample show the patterns that come up: the example describes what the team did instead of the applicant's own engineering actions, a code or standard is named without the specific clause, or the example does not match the competency (for instance, a contractual obligation used for the Code of Ethics, or a product standard used for the Role of Regulatory Bodies). Each comment asks for evidence the applicant can add in writing.

The amber panel is the regulator assessor's comment: the reason that competency was flagged. The numbered markers in the text open CertNova's review notes, and the Current / Suggested toggle shows how CertNova would rewrite the Action to answer the assessor.

Yes. In CBA Rejection Support a licensed P.Eng reads each returned competency against its assessor comment, maps each comment to a fix and gives you a revision plan, and you write the changes. It starts with a free 15-minute review of your comments on the CBA Rejection Support page. If a returned competency needs a new example altogether, CBA Pro can interview you about another of your own projects and turn your answers into a new draft.

Yes. Competency-based assessment and assessor comments are used across Canadian engineering regulators, including Professional Engineers Ontario (PEO), APEGA, EGBC, APEGS, and Engineers Geoscientists Manitoba (EGM). The fixes shown here apply to all of them: cite the exact clause, show your personal contribution and choose the right example. Always follow your regulator's official guidelines.

Not by itself. A returned CBA usually means specific competencies need clearer evidence or a better-matched example. Each association names the outcome and the deadline differently, so read your decision letter first. Our CBA Rejection Support page explains what returned means at PEO, APEGA, APEGS, EGBC and EGM.

Turn your own assessor comments into a revision plan

Free comment review. If you go ahead, a licensed P.Eng maps each comment to a fix, and you revise before you resubmit.

Educational sample only. Nobody can promise approval; your regulator decides.